I am of course going to comment on Sam Altman and his tin-eared comment on the likelihood that AI will have negative effects, such as, for example, eating all our jobs or destroying humanity: “we believe that the world should accept some bad things happening for the benefits of this technology and people having the agency.”
This week in my Micro class we are talking about externalities, which is exactly what Sam Altman does not know he is talking about. AI has lots of those, both positive and negative. It is surely too early to come up with a definitive list; however, someone should ask Sam if he is in principle ready to accept the principle that OpenAI should agree to pay to mitigate the negative effects of the creation and use of AI -- doing so would give him and all the other CEOs incentives to put guardrails in place.
This reminds me of globalization -- a reorientation of world trade patterns that released tremendous benefits for global economic growth, but had severe negative repercussions for many workers who lost jobs. If the principle of paying for negative externalities had been incorporated into this process from the beginning by, for example, retraining workers for new jobs in growing industries, a lot of workers would have been grateful instead of furious in the face of change, which would have saved us a ton of trouble.
And many other examples. Fossil fuel companies. Chemical companies. Etc.
Sooner or later something always eats the jobs. Turned out that in 2013 MOOCs did not eat all our jobs, but they did lead to Coursera and EdX and Khan Academy, which led to large-scale training for interested parties, plus jobs for the people who run them. But also, when we switched to LMSs, a fair number of colleagues, mostly older, decided to retire or get another job, because, in the words of many: "I didn't become an educator in order to operate a computer." Now we all run a computer as part of what we do, and don't even think about it -- except when the software changes.
The problem is not robots eating our jobs -- the problem would be if robots ate ALL of our jobs all at once. If that were to happen (and it sometimes does), we would either retire or we would need help getting new ones. Our skills would be obsolete. The US has historically been bad at helping workers in industries dying from technological unemployment (the term first used by Keynes in his 1930 Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren) to acquire skills in growing industries.
I didn't mean mere "incremental technological advancement" or "better tools". I literally meant if robots could replace all of our labor, all at once, that would be AMAZING. We wouldn't need jobs in the traditional sense.
Surely our problems would become different, new problems, but the loss of jobs would not itself be a problem, to my view.
Thanks for explaining. I heard more irony than was intended. I hope you're right. Keynes said so in 1930. Elon Musk has expressed something similar -- that with all the increased income produced by AI, we can all work only a little, and spend the rest of our time creating art, or poetry, or learning how to design rockets. That would be nice. As for me, I am learning AI skills as hard as I can.
I am of course going to comment on Sam Altman and his tin-eared comment on the likelihood that AI will have negative effects, such as, for example, eating all our jobs or destroying humanity: “we believe that the world should accept some bad things happening for the benefits of this technology and people having the agency.”
This week in my Micro class we are talking about externalities, which is exactly what Sam Altman does not know he is talking about. AI has lots of those, both positive and negative. It is surely too early to come up with a definitive list; however, someone should ask Sam if he is in principle ready to accept the principle that OpenAI should agree to pay to mitigate the negative effects of the creation and use of AI -- doing so would give him and all the other CEOs incentives to put guardrails in place.
This reminds me of globalization -- a reorientation of world trade patterns that released tremendous benefits for global economic growth, but had severe negative repercussions for many workers who lost jobs. If the principle of paying for negative externalities had been incorporated into this process from the beginning by, for example, retraining workers for new jobs in growing industries, a lot of workers would have been grateful instead of furious in the face of change, which would have saved us a ton of trouble.
And many other examples. Fossil fuel companies. Chemical companies. Etc.
One might argue that robots eating all our jobs would be a hugely *positive* effect.
Sooner or later something always eats the jobs. Turned out that in 2013 MOOCs did not eat all our jobs, but they did lead to Coursera and EdX and Khan Academy, which led to large-scale training for interested parties, plus jobs for the people who run them. But also, when we switched to LMSs, a fair number of colleagues, mostly older, decided to retire or get another job, because, in the words of many: "I didn't become an educator in order to operate a computer." Now we all run a computer as part of what we do, and don't even think about it -- except when the software changes.
The problem is not robots eating our jobs -- the problem would be if robots ate ALL of our jobs all at once. If that were to happen (and it sometimes does), we would either retire or we would need help getting new ones. Our skills would be obsolete. The US has historically been bad at helping workers in industries dying from technological unemployment (the term first used by Keynes in his 1930 Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren) to acquire skills in growing industries.
Ah. You misunderstand my meaning.
I didn't mean mere "incremental technological advancement" or "better tools". I literally meant if robots could replace all of our labor, all at once, that would be AMAZING. We wouldn't need jobs in the traditional sense.
Surely our problems would become different, new problems, but the loss of jobs would not itself be a problem, to my view.
Thanks for explaining. I heard more irony than was intended. I hope you're right. Keynes said so in 1930. Elon Musk has expressed something similar -- that with all the increased income produced by AI, we can all work only a little, and spend the rest of our time creating art, or poetry, or learning how to design rockets. That would be nice. As for me, I am learning AI skills as hard as I can.