The Market’s Down—But Is the Economy?
A falling stock market doesn’t cause a recession on its own—but it can help push the economy into recession territory. It's the reaction to the market, not just the market itself, that matters.
If you’ve glanced at your retirement account lately, you probably regretted it. As of this writing, the S&P 500 is down about 8% from the start of the year. The NASDAQ has dropped nearly 14%. And every news alert seems to bring more of the same: trade tensions, market slides, and talk of a looming recession.
I checked my own retirement account just before I sat down to write this—and quickly wished I hadn’t. I’m still decades away from retiring, but watching the numbers fall is nerve-wracking.
And I’m not alone. Over the past few weeks, I’ve been hearing the same question over and over: If the stock market’s crashing, does that mean the economy is too?
It’s a fair question. It’s also the wrong one. While the stock market and the economy are connected, they’re not the same thing.
Wait, isn’t the stock market the economy?
Not exactly, but the confusion is understandable. The stock market gets a lot of attention. It’s got tickers, charts, breaking news banners, and push notifications. It often moves in real time and gets more airtime than almost any other economic measure. Politicians love to point to it—especially when it’s up—as a scoreboard for how the country is doing.
So when the market drops, people assume the whole economy must be in trouble. Sometimes that’s true. In 2008, the stock market crashed because the economy was collapsing. The same thing, briefly, happened in early 2020. But those are the exceptions, not the rule.
Then how are they different?
The stock market moves on expectations—what people think is going to happen with profits, interest rates, inflation, and even international politics. If investors get nervous about the future, stock prices drop, even if the economy today is doing just fine.
On the other hand, the economy is a whole lot broader. It’s jobs, wages, rent, gas prices, groceries, and the cost of going to the doctor. It’s whether businesses are hiring or laying off, whether paychecks are keeping up with inflation, and whether people are buying homes or holding back. These are the kinds of signals economists look at. The stock market isn’t one of them—at least not directly.
Why the Market Feels Like the Economy
Part of the confusion comes down to timing. Economic data is slow. Jobs reports, inflation numbers, GDP growth—they usually come out once a month and often reflect conditions from several weeks earlier. By the time you read a headline about wage growth or consumer spending, the data can be six weeks old.
The stock market, on the other hand, feels like it never stops talking. It updates by the second. It flashes red or green on your phone. It reacts instantly to news, rumors, social media posts, and guesses about what the Federal Reserve might do next. That makes it feel like a real-time report card for the entire economy.
And then there’s the messaging aspect of it all. When markets rise, politicians take credit. When they fall, cable news fills with speculation about economic collapse. To make things even more confusing, the stock market can influence the economy. When the market drops, people get anxious. They might put off big purchases, scale back travel plans, or postpone retirement. Companies might hold off on hiring or expansion.
That’s the start of a negative feedback loop: The market reacts to bad news → People react to the market → Spending slows → The economy actually weakens.
So while the stock market isn’t the economy, it can become part of the story if enough people start treating it like it is.
Final thoughts
If the stock market isn’t the economy, then what is? When economists try to figure out how things are going, they look at people, prices, and behavior. Here are a few examples of economic indicators that you can dig into:
Start with the labor market: Are businesses adding jobs? Are people coming back into the workforce, or quietly dropping out? Steady job growth is usually a good sign that the economy is holding up.
Then there’s wage growth. Are paychecks rising fast enough to keep up with inflation? If not, even a booming job market might not feel great for most households.
Look at consumer spending. Are people still going out to eat, traveling, and buying stuff they don’t strictly need? When that slows down, it’s often an early sign of economic trouble.
Keep an eye on inflation—not just whether prices are rising, but how fast they’re rising. That tells you a lot about purchasing power and how the Fed might respond.
These indicators don’t update every minute. Most come out monthly. They reflect what has actually happened in the economy—not just what investors are worried might happen down the line. We’ve spent the past month living in a moment of uncertainty, and the markets are acting like it. That doesn’t necessarily mean a recession is around the corner—but it does mean we need to pay attention.
As for me, I’ll keep an eye on the jobs report, inflation data, and spending trends. I’ll also eventually check my retirement account. Probably.
Thank you for reading Monday Morning Economist! This free weekly newsletter explores the economics behind pop culture and current events. This newsletter lands in the inbox of more than 6,800 subscribers every week! You can support this newsletter by sharing this free post or becoming a paid supporter:
Back in 1929, the US stock market lost over 20% of its value in two days, and 50% within three weeks [Mint]
Personal income increased $194.7 billion (0.8% at a monthly rate) in February 2025 [U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis]
In February 2025, the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers rose 2.8% since the same time last year [U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics]
Real gross domestic product (GDP) increased at an annual rate of 2.4% in the last three months of 2024 [U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis]
The international trade deficit in goods and services decreased by $8.0 billion in February 2025 compared to the month before [U.S. Census Bureau]
Consumer spending powers the economy. As market losses close businesses and threaten citizen's investments, savings, retirement accounts, consumers will slow spending to just the essentials for life. This will close more businesses. At the same time, shortages of many goods not made in the US will create hoarding and raise prices on available goods (inflation). This will create more panic and contraction of spending and growth. There are hard time ahead, I think.