An Economic Perspective on Service Fees
An Economic Perspective on Service Fees
Why don’t restaurants just increase the prices of the dishes instead?
Thank you for reading Monday Morning Economist! This is a free weekly newsletter that explores the economics behind pop culture and current events. This newsletter lands in the inbox of more than 4,500 subscribers every week! You can support this newsletter by sharing this free post or becoming a paid supporter:
Even though inflation has been steady over the past few months, it’s still higher than what we’re used to, and with minimum wage hikes spreading across the United States, restaurants have spent the past year looking for ways to stay profitable. One strategy they’ve adopted is adding service fees and surcharges when it comes time for customers to pay the tab.
A lot of people, including politicians, are getting frustrated with these additional charges. We’re seeing these so-called “junk fees” everywhere—from booking hotels to buying concert tickets—and it’s becoming a major part of our economic landscape. However, service charges added to restaurant bills are a little different since they’re often applied in the context of some increased cost that the restaurant has incurred. So then why don’t restaurants just increase the prices of the dishes instead? Well, there’s some solid economic reasoning behind this growing trend.
The Economic Reality of Higher Costs
At the heart of the issue for restaurant owners is the fact that higher wages and inflation have increased the cost of producing meals. It’s a straightforward concept: if it costs more to pay workers, it will eventually cost people more to buy the products or services they produce. Similarly, if inflation is driving up the cost of ingredients, the final meal will likely cost more as well if diners aren’t seeing increases in real wages.
But here’s the catch—simply raising prices to cover these higher costs isn’t always a viable solution for business owners. Higher prices lead to a reduction in the quantity demanded, which means customers will buy less than they were before. This is especially tricky in highly competitive markets where consumers have many alternatives and are very sensitive to price changes. For businesses operating on thin margins, a significant drop in sales volume could be devastating. So, what can restaurants do to appear competitively priced but also cover all these new costs of doing business? That’s where service fees come in.
The Concept of Sticky Prices and Menu Costs
This brings us to a less commonly discussed but equally important economic concept: sticky prices. Sticky prices refer to the resistance of prices to change quickly, even when the economic conditions shift and the cost of producing and selling items changes. So, why are prices slow to change? One of the primary reasons is the existence of menu costs.
Menu costs originally meant the literal cost of printing new menus in restaurants. But nowadays, it covers a lot more. It includes updating pricing information on websites, reconfiguring point-of-sale systems, communicating changes to customers, and even dealing with the potential negative reactions from customers when prices change frequently.
For businesses, especially those with lots of products or multiple locations, these menu costs can be significant. Because of this, firms often prefer to keep prices stable for as long as possible, even when their costs are rising. If owners are slow to change those prices, they’ll need to find other ways to cover their increased costs.
Service Fees as a Solution to Sticky Prices
So, how are restaurants dealing with sticky prices and menu costs? Enter: service fees. Service fees offer business owners a potential solution to the problem of sticky prices. By adding a separate charge to cover specific costs, businesses can avoid the disruptions and expenses of changing their base prices. It’s a way to cope with higher costs without constantly updating their prices.
This strategy allows restaurants to respond more flexibly to economic pressures, like increased labor costs or inflation, without constantly adjusting their price lists. From an economic perspective, service fees help separate the pricing of the core product or service from the additional costs imposed by external factors.
For instance, a restaurant might add a service fee to cover the increased wages of its staff. This way, they can keep their menu prices competitive while still ensuring they can pay their workers fairly. The perceived value of the meal remains the same, but the restaurant can still cover its higher expenses.
Another big advantage of service fees is their flexibility. They can be adjusted more easily and frequently than menu prices. This is crucial in a volatile economic environment where costs might change often, as we’ve seen with inflation over the past year. By using service fees, businesses can adapt quickly to changes without the hassle of constantly recalibrating their prices.
The Customer Perspective
Despite the economic rationale behind service fees, this practice hasn’t been without controversy. Many customers see these fees as deceptive or unfair, especially when they aren’t clearly communicated upfront. The feeling of being "nickel-and-dimed" can reduce loyalty, leading to negative customer experiences and potentially driving business away.
Transparency is key here. Businesses that choose to implement service fees should clearly explain the reasons for these charges and how they benefit both the company and its employees. Providing detailed information about the allocation of service fees can help customers understand and accept the additional costs. For example, restaurants can include notes on their menus or websites explaining that service fees are used to pay higher wages or provide benefits to staff.
Let’s look at a real-life example: Initiative 82, passed in Washington DC in November 2022, eliminated the tipped minimum wage for servers, bartenders, and other tipped workers. In response, many businesses started adding a service fee to cover the rising costs and informed customers that they no longer needed to tip. However, some owners still gave customers the option to tip, which led to confusion and instances of accidental double-tipping.
Some restaurants were setting fees so high that the city had to pass another ordinance, capping service fees to 20% at restaurants. The Office of the Attorney General had to step in and provide guidance on service fee disclosures that were compliant with the District’s consumer protection laws. While service fees can help restaurants manage their costs, they need to be upfront and transparent about these charges to maintain customer trust and satisfaction.
Final Thoughts
The rise of service fees across the country is a direct response to the economic pressures of rising costs in an industry with already thin profit margins. While these fees can be frustrating for consumers, they are rooted in economic theory. Sticky prices and menu costs make frequent price adjustments impractical, prompting companies to use service fees as a more flexible and transparent solution.
By recognizing that these fees are a response to broader economic forces, we can better appreciate the challenges businesses face in balancing fair wages with competitive pricing. As this trend continues, the key for businesses will be to maintain transparency and communication, ensuring that customers feel informed and respected in their transactions.
So next time you see a service fee on your restaurant bill, you’ll know there’s a lot more to it than just an extra charge. It’s a strategy that helps businesses navigate a complex economic landscape while trying to keep things fair for their employees and competitive for their customers.
Initiative 82, which increased the minimum wage for tipped employees in Washington, D.C. was approved with 73.94% of the vote [Ballotpedia]
There are 2,513 restaurants located in Washington, DC [Destination DC]
There were 3,740 bartenders and 11,640 waiters/waitresses working in Washington, D.C. in 2023 [U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics]
In a December 2022 report on business conditions in the restaurant industry, 15% of restaurants planned to add surcharges to checks as a result of higher costs [National Restaurant Association]