
Two news stories popped up in my feed this weekāboth about animals adapting to environmental changes. At first glance, they had nothing in common. But from an economic perspective, they shared something crucial. Before we get into that, letās run a quick thought experiment.
Imagine thereās an ATM in your neighborhood, but not just any ATMāthis one is stocked with cash and doesnāt require a PIN or a card. Anyone who knows where itās located can take out as much money as they want. Any leftover cash at the end of the day earns interest, meaning there could be even more to withdraw tomorrow.
How long would it take before you paid this ATM a visit? And how much would you take on your first trip?
If you were the only one who knew about it, youād probably be careful with how much you take out. You might withdraw a little, but youād also let it growāmaybe just skimming off the interest each day while keeping the balance high. You might even add money to the ATM, knowing it would pay off over time. After all, when something belongs to us, we tend to take better care of it.
But what if the whole neighborhood found out about your ATM? Suddenly, your carefully managed cash stash turns into a free-for-all. Neighbors drop by in the morning for some quick cash. Strangers take their cut. And now youāre faced with a dilemma: wait too long, and there might be nothing left. The incentive shifts from long-term preservation to grabbing as much as possible before itās gone. No matter how high the interest rate, the balance will never growābecause there wonāt be any money left.

Our hypothetical scenario isnāt just a neighborhood run amokāitās a modern-day version of the tragedy of the commons, an economic dilemma that plagues resources with two key characteristics.
First, thereās rivalry. If one personās use of a resource directly reduces how much is left for everyone else, youāve got a problem. Your neighbor clearing out the ATM before you get there is a perfect exampleāonce the moneyās gone, itās gone. A fishery facing overfishing, an overgrazed pasture, or a congested freeway during rush hour? Same issue. One personās consumption leaves less (or nothing) for others.
But rivalry alone doesnāt cause a tragedy. The real problem? Lack of ownership. In our ATM scenario, there are no clear property rightsāno rules governing who can access the cash or how much they can take. That creates a perverse incentive: grab what you can before someone else does. When you were the only one who knew about the ATM, you had every reason to be careful. You saw the money as yours and treated it like a long-term investment. But once access became free-for-all, patience and conservation went out the window.
This is what separates common resources from private goods. You could, in theory, walk into Old Navy and buy every pair of jeans in stock, leaving none for other shoppers. But you canāt just take them without paying. Thatās the crucial differenceāprivate ownership gives businesses control over how resources are allocated, preventing depletion.
Of course, simply privatizing everything isnāt always a perfect solution. Elinor Ostrom, the first woman to win the Nobel Prize in Economics, spent her career studying how societies manage common resources without falling into tragedy. Her research showed that well-designed community rulesārather than just government mandates or private ownershipācan help preserve shared resources. In 2009, she won the Nobel for showing that the tragedy of the commons isnāt inevitable.
Lobster Wars and Warmer Waters
Forget the hypothetical ATMāletās talk about real-world resources that generate serious economic value: lobsters, whales, and elephants. Each has been threatened by overexploitation, and without intervention, each faces the risk of depletion or extinction. Even where governments have stepped in, illegal activity and environmental shifts continue to test conservation efforts.
Take lobsters. In the Gulf of Maine, lobster populations are thriving, but just south, in Southern New England, theyāre dangerously low. Why? One big reason: warming waters. Meanwhile, off the coast of Africa, poachers have driven elephant populations to critically low levels in pursuit of ivory. And though commercial whaling is largely a thing of the past, the North Atlantic right whale still struggles to recover from centuries of overhunting.
Each of these species has experienced its own version of the tragedy of the commons, but now, climate change is adding a new layer of complexity. Policies that once worked may no longer be enough.
Maine has some of the richest fishing grounds in the world, and lobster is its crown jewel. But thatās only because of strict government regulations designed to prevent overfishing. Without them, the market would quickly deplete the resource, just as it has in Southern New England.
The problem? The ocean isnāt staying the same. Over the past few decades, rising water temperatures have pushed lobster populations northward, away from their traditional habitats. The documentary Lobster War details the tensions this has created, particularly as fishermen from different regionsāand even different countriesācompete for access to this high-value resource.
For now, Maineās lobster population is considered āappropriately stocked.ā But early warning signs are appearing: the size of lobster and soft-shell crab catches has declined in recent years. If Maineās waters continue warming, its lobster population may follow the same downward trajectory as New Englandās. And as the resource becomes scarcer, incentives to overfish will only grow.
But lobsters arenāt the only ones moving north.

Whales vs. Fishing Vessels
The North Atlantic right whale isnāt being hunted anymore, but that doesnāt mean itās safe. Its primary food source has been disappearing due to warming waters, forcing the whales to migrate farther north in search of sustenance. And thatās putting them in increasing dangerānot from harpoons, but from fishing vessels.
Lobster fishing may be sustainable for now, but it comes with external costs. As boats head out to sea, they unintentionally threaten the already endangered right whale. In recent years, two-thirds of known whale deaths have been caused by fishing-related incidentsāeither from ship strikes or entanglement in nets.
Hereās where the economic trade-off gets complicated. Maineās lobster industry generates billions of dollars and supports thousands of jobs. Right whale tourism, on the other hand, also brings in revenue but relies on the whales surviving. The more fishing vessels spend time at seaāespecially as they chase dwindling lobster populationsāthe greater the risk to the whales.
Itās a classic externality problem: the economic activity that benefits one group (lobster fishermen) imposes costs on another (whale conservationists and tourism operators). Balancing these competing interests will be a growing challenge as environmental conditions continue to change.
The Evolution of an Anti-Poaching Defense
Now letās shift from the sea to the savanna. Decades of elephant poaching in Africa, driven by demand for ivory, have left some populations in crisis. Even with strict government protections, illegal poaching remains a persistent threat. But in Mozambique, something remarkable has happened: evolution may be fighting back.
Some elephants are born with a rare genetic trait that leaves them tuskless. Historically, this was an uncommon occurrence. But because poachers exclusively targeted elephants with tusks, those without them had a survival advantage. Over time, this trait became far more common. Itās a real-world case of selective pressureāpoaching altered the genetic landscape of the elephant population.

At first glance, this might seem like a win: fewer tusked elephants means less incentive for poachers. But thereās a catch. In males, this tuskless trait is linked to lower reproductive success, which could ultimately reduce birth rates and weaken population recovery in the long run.
Itās a stark example of how human economic behaviorāspecifically, the pursuit of valuable resourcesācan shape the very evolution of a species. And it raises an important question: even if elephants become less valuable to poachers, will their populations still decline due to these unintended genetic consequences?
Final Thoughts
The tragedy of the commons isnāt a static problemāit shifts with the environment. Regulations that once worked may need to be rethought as species migrate, adapt, or face new threats.
Maineās lobster industry is currently well-managed, but warming waters could push the fishery past its tipping point.
Right whales, no longer at risk from whaling, now face a different threat: the very vessels that sustain Maineās lobster economy.
Elephants may be evolving a defense against poachers, but the long-term genetic effects could introduce new challenges.
Elinor Ostromās research showed that commons problems can be solvedānot just through government mandates, but through cooperative management and well-designed incentives. The challenge now is adapting conservation efforts in real time to account for climate shifts, economic pressures, and even the unexpected consequences of evolution itself.

Over the past 30 years, the Gulf of Maine has warmed faster than 99% of the worldās ocean [The Economist]
An estimated $668 million worth of lobster was caught in the United States in 2019 [National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration]
There are only an estimated 368 living North Atlantic right whales left in the world [National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration]
Around 90% of Mozambiqueās elephant population was slaughtered by poachers between 1977 to 1992 [The Telegraph]

Week #42 is done and Iāve checked in a total of 61 books so far this year. This past week I finished up Four Hundred Souls, which looks at 400 years of different people and events that have influenced the journey of African Americans in the United States. The centuries are broken up into 5-year intervals and each has a different author.
If youāre looking for a good book related to this weekās topic, I would highly recommend Endangered Economies by Geoffrey Heal. The book looks at issues in natural resource economics like pollution, climate change, and common resource problems. I used this book in my Natural Resource Economics course in 2020 and loved it.


